Matches decided by 1 goals or less for NYC
| Date | Team 1 | Team 2 | +/- | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feb 22 | R1 | MIA | 2 -2 | NYC | 0 |
| Mar 22 | R5 | CLB | 0 -0 | NYC | 0 |
| May 14 | R13 | DCU | 0 -0 | NYC | 0 |
| May 31 | R17 | NSH | 2 -2 | NYC | 0 |
| Jul 19 | R25 | SKC | 1 -1 | NYC | 0 |
| Mar 1 | R2 | LAFC | 1 -0 | NYC | 1 |
| Mar 8 | R3 | NYC | 2 -1 | ORL | 1 |
| Mar 15 | R4 | NYC | 2 -1 | NER | 1 |
| Mar 29 | R6 | ATL | 4 -3 | NYC | 1 |
| Apr 6 | R7 | NYC | 1 -2 | MIN | 1 |
| Apr 12 | R8 | NYC | 1 -0 | PHI | 1 |
| Apr 26 | R10 | TOR | 0 -1 | NYC | 1 |
| May 4 | R11 | NYC | 1 -0 | CIN | 1 |
| May 10 | R12 | NYC | 0 -1 | MTL | 1 |
| Jun 28 | R21 | MTL | 1 -0 | NYC | 1 |
| Jul 16 | R24 | ORL | 1 -2 | NYC | 1 |
| Jul 25 | R26 | DAL | 3 -4 | NYC | 1 |
| Apr 19 | R9 | NER | 2 -0 | NYC | 2 |
| May 17 | R14 | NYC | 2 -0 | RBNY | 2 |
| May 25 | R15 | NYC | 3 -1 | CHI | 2 |
| Jul 3 | R22 | NYC | 3 -1 | TOR | 2 |
| Jul 12 | R23 | CHA | 2 -0 | NYC | 2 |
| May 28 | R16 | NYC | 0 -3 | HOU | 3 |
| Jun 12 | R19 | NYC | 4 -0 | ATL | 4 |